Public Goods, Common Resources, and Externalities

Different Types of Goods

  • Public Goods: neither excludable nor rival, free market does a very BAD job.
  • Private Goods: both excludable and rival, free market is very efficient in distributing such goods.
  • Club Goods: excludable but not rival, market does an OK job
  • Common Resource: not excludable but rival, market does a very BAD job.

Public Goods

  • Free-rider problem
  • Solutions
    • Advertising
    • Forcing everyone to pay
  • Cost-benefit analysis can be sophisticated in some cases.

Common Resources

  • Tragedy of the Commons = if all the boats belong to one company, less boats will be sent out… A single company controlling the whole industry will consider the cost and benefits globally.
  • Solutions
    • Property rights and quotas.
    • Tolls

Externalities

  • Externality (either positive or negative)
    • An agent engages in an activity which changes the welfare of another agent
    • The change in welfare goes uncompensated
  • Problem is, the pollution cost is hard to measure, i.e. hard to internalize the externalities
  • Negative externality creates too much of a thing, positive externality creates too little of a thing
  • Private solution
    • “Coase Theorem”, as long as we can assign property rights, externalities can be internalized by negotiation
    • Sometimes transaction cost is too high to bring all agents together.
  • Governmental solution
    • Pollution quota
    • Tax, in such case the quota can be traded among companies